Category: default || By jt3y
I wasn't able to attend Mayor Brewster's briefing session for public officials on the Mon-Fayette Expressway --- real life, surprisingly, has a tendency to bump aside work I'd like to do on the Almanac --- but Jen Vertullo of the Daily News had a nice story (subscribers-only link) in Tuesday's paper, and Eric Slagle followed up in Thursday's Post-Gazette.
Brewster and others called on leaders in Mon-Yough area municipalities to band together and pressure state and federal elected officials for money for property acquisition to push through the right-of-way from the Route 51 interchange in Large to the Parkway East in Monroeville.
If completed, the Mon-Fayette would bypass congested surface roads like routes 837, 48 and 51 and provide a high-speed link between the Parkway East and Interstate 68 in West Virginia. Brewster and others (notably the Mon Valley Progress Council, whose Joe Kirk has been lobbying for the highway's completion for decades) say the road is necessary to spur brownfield development.
. . .
Boy, I have mixed emotions about this, and not only because my house is going to be one well-thrown jug of urine from the southbound lanes.
I love to drive, and I've done a fair amount of driving throughout the northeast in the past 10 years. I've been to garden spots like Akron, Dayton, Rochester, Buffalo, Wheeling and Youngstown. All of those towns have easy interstate highway access.
Youngstown, for instance, has a nice six-lane expressway cutting right through the middle of town. Dayton's at the junction of two interstates and also has a bypass. Yet you'd be hard pressed to find a town more downtrodden than Youngstown --- beaten up, like the Mon Valley, by the collapse of the steel industry in the late '70s. Dayton, which was once heavily reliant on jobs from "Generous Motors" subsidiaries like Frigidaire and Delco, hasn't bottomed out yet.
I've never seen any evidence that brownfield development in those places has been spurred by the expressways, and expressways sure didn't stop the rubber industry from moving out of Akron, or Kodak from laying off thousands of people in Rochester.
For a local example, take a ride down to Washington, Pa. (aka "Little Worshington"), which sits at the junction of two interstates—one that runs all the way to the Gulf of Mexico and the other from coast-to-coast. The outskirts of Washington County are booming (mostly with retail development and McMansions) but the city has had blighted sections for a long time.
. . .
My point, and I do have one, is that I don't see this toll road (the Angry Drunk Bureaucrat calls it the "Mo-Fo Excessway") as a cure for all of the problems facing the region.
In fact, I have a strong feeling that all the Mo-Fo will do is move people further out into mostly-rural places like Union Township and Nottingham Township. Suddenly you'll be able to work in the Golden Triangle and live in Gastonville, just as I-279 made it practical to live in Wexford or Cranberry.
But as far as I can tell, I-279 hasn't helped Pittsburgh's North Side at all --- and I don't think the Mo-Fo is going to provide much benefit to the communities it passes through. Commuters and long-haul truck drivers will barely pay attention to us as they whiz past (and I do mean whiz).
. . .
There are many reasons companies don't want to locate here, but the quickest answer (in my humble opinion) is that it's harder to redevelop a brownfield than to plow up 40 acres of farmland somewhere and pave it.
Factor in the Mon-Yough area's reputation as a place with "high taxes, corruption and high crime" (three things that I think have been greatly exaggerated) and building an office park out in some pasture instead of McKeesport or Duquesne becomes an easy choice for corporate planners.
No highway is going to change that equation.
If the Turnpike Commission wants to sell the Mo-Fo as a way to bypass congested surface roads or to open up rural Washington and Fayette counties to development, that's fine. But trying to ram this through the Mon-Yough area as the be-all, end-all for economic development is suspect.
. . .
If we want to spur economic development, I suspect we'd be better off trying to get our Mon-Yough area communities to adopt uniform zoning and planning codes and taxation rates, along with regional public safety and public works services.
And I still don't understand why we aren't marketing the entire McKeesport area --- not just the city or the school district --- with a unified effort. There are real housing bargains in the Mon-Yough district and a lot of cultural and educational amenities that make it an attractive place for middle-income people trying to start a family.
Instead of worrying about what the Turnpike Commission might or might not do, working on those issues might make Our Fair City and the surrounding communities a lot more attractive to potential residents.
And I'm not just saying that because I don't want to have a front yard full of trucker bombs.
. . .
In Other News: McKeesport Recreation Committee's website reports that the Mon-Yough Riverfront Entertainment Council has been dissolved. The city recreation committee says it will do what it can to keep entertainment and cultural activities going.
This is sad news. We need more regional cooperation, not less, but good on the rec committee for stepping up, I guess.
. . .
To Do This Weekend: The Mon Valley Youth Symphony Orchestra makes its public debut at 3 p.m. Sunday with a special concert at the First Free Evangelical Church, 4001 University Drive, with Maestro Bruce Lauffer of the McKeesport Symphony Orchestra conducting. Admission is free. Come out and support these great student musicians ... Speaking of student musicians, it's high school musical time, and McKeesport Area High School, 1960 Eden Park Blvd., is presenting "Crazy for You" at 7:30 p.m. tonight, tomorrow and Saturday. Admission is $7. East Allegheny High School, 1150 Jacks Run Road (Route 48) in North Versailles presents "Cinderella" tonight and Saturday at 7:30 p.m. and Sunday at 3 p.m. Admission is $7 for adults and $5 for students and seniors. ... McKeesport Recreation Committee will hold an Easter egg hunt Saturday morning at the Jacob Woll Pavilion in Renzie Park (rain date is April 7). Check their website for details.
WOOO!! Youngstown representin’!
You didn’t see the blimp factory? Or the Avanti factory? Or the Pentagon payroll center? Or the Phar-Mor Centre? All of which were supposed to be keys to the valley’s economic revitalization.
But from the Madison Avenue Expressway, you can see projects that give the projects a bad name.
Vince - March 30, 2007
“If we want to spur economic development, I suspect we’d be better off trying to get our Mon-Yough area communities to adopt uniform zoning and planning codes and taxation rates, along with regional public safety and public works services.”
I’m reminded of a Chuck Noll quote: “Sidney has many problems and they are g r e a t.” Coach Noll was replying to a question concerning a Steeler running back who had experienced a particularly bad afternoon. The Mon Valley is in its third particularly bad decade. In all that time the only big idea that has enjoyed a measure of unified local support has been the Mon/Fayette Expressway (MFX) project. It’s touted as the key to a second coming of economic prosperity. As I see it, the likely best case will yield a continuous string of moneyed patrons traveling the MFX from West Virginia to make a cash deposit at the Majestic Star Casino on the North Side. The resulting property tax relief will seed a Mon Valley real estate boom that will have many locals crying for New York City style rent control.
Mayor Brewster and others have said that the lack of easy highway access has been a deal breaker for companies who have considered locating here. I’m sure Chrysler, Volkswagen and Sony were not among them. I don’t envy community leaders fighting urban decay in a world where NAFTA, GATT and the WTO lubricate the slide for jobs landing in low wage countries. This is a national issue that requires a holistic solution. I believe that your suggestion of uniform local codes and regional services should be a priority. We also need Washington to rework our international trade accords and the State to tackle significant public education reform. Lacking that, the Mon/Fayette Expressway is simply an unaffordable idea from another time.
Strisi - April 01, 2007
To comment on any story at Tube City Almanac, email tubecitytiger@gmail.com, send a tweet to www.twitter.com/tubecityonline, visit our Facebook page, or write to Tube City Almanac, P.O. Box 94, McKeesport, PA 15134.